NMPA suing XM Radio for copyright infringement - Engadget

Question: How is allowing MP3 recording of over the air broadcasting (Satellite, in this case) any different that being able to record radio to a cassette tape? And forget about all the “copy of a copy” and “copy degradation” crap.

The only difference is the US’s broken copyright/legal system and the fact the DMCA-powered companies are smelling dollar signs.